Detective Stories

Sturgis Hartman Smith Fish Jones Bull
Back row, left to right: Mercy Elizabeth (Fish) Smith, Edgar Leslie Smith, Cyrus Cressey Sturgis, Angeline (Hartman) Sturgis. Front row, left to right: Berintha Lydia (Bull) Fish, Una Coy (Smith) Sturgis with Cyrus Cressey Sturgis Jr., Jane (Jones) Hartman. Author’s Collection

A few nights ago, I was watching Hercule Poirot on TV, working to solve a complicated mystery. At one point, he found himself stumped and said, “I am an imbecile. I see only half of the picture.” As an aspiring genealogist (read: amateur detective), I can certainly identify with the great detective in that way. I get that feeling all the time! I feel much more like Miss Lemon, who replies, “I don’t even see that.”

I guess it’s common knowledge that many aspiring (and even accomplished) genealogists see genealogy as a British murder mystery, a puzzle just begging to be solved. I know I do. And I have at least as much trouble solving my genealogical puzzles as Hercule, Miss Marple, and, dare I say it, Inspector Morse. Of course, the big difference is that those fictional detectives solve every case by the end of the episode. We genealogists can struggle for years, trying to solve our mysteries. Fortunately, very few of our cases involve murder.

When I first developed an interest in genealogy, I was extremely spoiled by the fact that it seemed as though previous genealogists had already done the bulk of the hard work. My wife’s older sister had been presented with a family tree by her great-aunt and -uncle, done in 1937, and it had only a few blank spots. I thought: I’ll see if I can fill those in! Well, I think I filled in only one, but I was able to confirm much of the rest of the tree, mainly by referring to the many compiled genealogies found at NEHGS. My wife’s families are all primarily from New England, which was a lucky break. So I decided to look into the Sturgis family. The Sturgis family settled on Cape Cod in the seventeenth century and again, there are several compiled genealogies that detail many branches of the family, including all the way down to my great-great-great-grandparents. Gee, this genealogy isn’t so tough! You just have to find the right book, and it’s all laid out there for you!

It wasn’t until I started investigating my paternal grandmother’s family that things got interesting.  Hmm. Grandmother’s maiden name was Smith. Fortunately (for genealogical purposes), her mother’s name was ‘Fish’ and her maternal grandmother’s name was ‘Bull.’ I seem to remember Grandmother saying, “Well, when you look at my family, it’s all fish and bull.” The Fish and Bull families were in Massachusetts in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, and their genealogies are also pretty well established. But those pesky Smiths

The “Smith problem” (or, should I say “challenge”?) caused me to temporarily turn to my paternal great-grandmother’s family. Let’s see. Her name was Angeline Hartman. Good! And her mother’s name was …  Jane Jones. Jones? Well, maybe these people were all from Massachusetts, too. Let me just check some of Grandmother’s notes.

Hmm. “With the exception of the Sturgis, Fish, and Bull families, everyone came to Oregon and Washington from Tennessee. And, the Fish family had departed from Massachusetts many years before, with stops in New York, Ontario, and Missouri, before taking the Oregon Trail to Oregon in the 1860’s.” Fortunately, grandmother had made detailed notes of her families and had saved the record page from a family bible of the Jones and Hartman families. And I’ve been able to find various civil records of the births, marriages, and deaths of several of the ancestors. So light is beginning to dawn on that side of the family.

Now for my mother’s side of the family. Her grandfather’s name: ‘Timothy McCarthy.’  (Hmm.) Timothy’s  father’s name: ‘Patrick McCarthy.’ (Uh-oh.)  Tim’s mother’s name: ‘Mary Ryan.’  (Heavy sigh…)

Yes, genealogy’s got it all. The whole thing laid out for you by some hard-working nineteenth-, twentieth-, or twenty-first-century genealogist. Or, much more likely, you’ve got the opportunity to do what the old-timers did: Solve a mystery that would stump Hercule Poirot. (Temporarily, at least!)

About Sam Sturgis

Sam was born and raised in Ann Arbor, Michigan. He received B.S. and M.S. degrees in Psychology from Eastern Michigan University and worked as a Human Factors researcher in automotive safety for 13 years. He entered the field of commercial software development in 1983 and acted as software developer and development manager at Wang Laboratories and The Foxboro Company. Sam joined the NEHGS staff in 2005. Sam's interest in genealogy began shortly after moving to Massachusetts, when he and his family chanced upon the Sturgis Library in Barnstable, during a vacation on Cape Cod. There he discovered that he is a descendent of the Sturgis family that settled on Cape Cod in the 1630's. Sam and his wife Gail live in Medway, Massachusetts. They have two grown children: Katie, a Registered Nurse in Wrentham, and David, a software developer in Somerville.

5 thoughts on “Detective Stories

  1. There are those problems with the names Smith, the Jones, etc. but then there are problems with the more unusual names too. You’d think they would “pop right out” at you, but then those census takers and county clerks didn’t know how to spell (or hear?) them right and there could be several iterations of a name’s spelling. But that’s what keeps it challenging and interesting.

  2. I’ve always thought of genealogical research as a jigsaw puzzle – only without defined borders and with pieces missing!

  3. That is what makes it fun! I was able to identify the people in an unlabeled picture the other day, based on one I could identify, the adult, and realizing which of her son’s had 5 children of the right ages to be in a picture with their grandmother in the early 20th century (I figure 1915 from ages and clothing)

  4. Granny was Elizabeth Smith (Beth) Born in Pendleton.. The Smith house still stands and of course you would know that the family farm in Helix still is in the family. My husband is the Elizabeth Smith’s grandson.. She married a Fitzgibbon. We would love more pictures if you have them.. We live in Pendleton Oregon.. and I am the chair of the National Historic Oregon Trail Interpretive Center Trail Tender board of directors.. if you have more information let us know..

  5. Granny is Elizabeth Smith. We live in Pendleton Oregon and are having trouble trying to find the ranch. Have you the address? We have also noticed that on Memorial day along with our flowers someone else is leaving flowers over at Olney on the Smith Family Grave site.. We know Cousin Rhoda is in Walla Walla, is there any other members of the family here in Pendleton?

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.